Commons:Deletion requests/File:Maneka Gandhi.jpg
File:Maneka Gandhi.jpg[edit]
COPYVIO: Entire websiite is copyrighted asserted. The (generic ?) OTRS permission is subject to the photo being taken by Bollywood Hungama photographer. Photographer / Author unknown and no author in EXIF. Unfitlouie (talk) 01:33, 27 April 2016 (UTC)
Delete
Keep it is a derivative work of the source wich covered by the OTRS ticket, that's seems ok...Christian Ferrer (talk) 05:11, 4 May 2016 (UTC)
- Christian Ferrer I have spent a good amount of time rereading through the OTRS ticket in entirety. I have stricken my delete vote because I was operating under the specifics in the ticket that stated that each individual file from Bollywood Hungama must go through the OTRS process and be confirmed. Instead, it seems Template:Cc-by-3.0-BollywoodHungama is being used and the OTRS confirmation is being replaced with confirmation from image reviewers. While this is swaying away from what the ticket states, confirmation through OTRS was a request by the OTRS agent and not the copyright holder. This file therefore looks safe to Keep. Riley Huntley (talk) 06:22, 4 May 2016 (UTC)
- Christian Ferrer I have spent a good amount of time rereading through the OTRS ticket in entirety. I have stricken my delete vote because I was operating under the specifics in the ticket that stated that each individual file from Bollywood Hungama must go through the OTRS process and be confirmed. Instead, it seems Template:Cc-by-3.0-BollywoodHungama is being used and the OTRS confirmation is being replaced with confirmation from image reviewers. While this is swaying away from what the ticket states, confirmation through OTRS was a request by the OTRS agent and not the copyright holder. This file therefore looks safe to
Kept: This retouched crop out of this source photograph appears to be covered by the very generic grant connected with ticket:2008030310010794. File:Maneka Gandhi.jpg is from the Bollywood Hungama website, carries a watermark refering to that site and is from the Bollywood event “Trailer launch of 'It's Entertainment'”. The photographer is unfortunately not named but I haven't seen yet any eligible photo from that site where the photographer is named. Such generic grants are naturally not without risks. This ticket is from 2008 and there was no contact with the copyright holder since then. Fortunately, the director of the site (who is named at [1]) is still at that position and hence it is likely that we still have the understanding from 2008. --AFBorchert (talk) 20:43, 4 May 2016 (UTC)
File:Maneka Gandhi.jpg[edit]
This file's parent image is not created by exclusive photographer of Bollywoodhungama.com. Many other copies (better quality without bollywoodhungama watermark) are in internet. eg. http://www.indicine.com/movies/bollywood/maneka-gandhi-launches-the-trailer-of-its-entertainment-pics/ and http://sharestills.com/image.php?category=3&subcategory=1&gallery=0&photoevent=Maneka%20Gandhi%20Launches%20Trailer%20Of%20Akshay%20Kumars%20Film%20Its%20Entertainment&imagecount=17&totalimages=27&basename=Its%20Entertainment Sigmabaroda (talk) 06:05, 6 May 2016 (UTC)
Kept, socks must go back to the drawer. Taivo (talk) 09:14, 26 May 2016 (UTC)
